My Apple Tree Has Stopped Fruiting — What is Wrong With It?
Share
A garden apple tree that has given good crops for many years and suddenly stopped, or one that flowers abundantly in spring but produces little or no fruit, is something that comes up in conversations across Grange-over-Sands, Kendal and the villages of the Cartmel Peninsula more often than you might expect. As tree surgeons we visit a lot of gardens, and the state of the apple tree comes up in conversation regularly.
The causes of poor fruiting are almost always identifiable and often fixable. This guide covers the most common ones.
The Tree is Not Being Pollinated
This is the most common cause of apple trees flowering but producing no fruit. Apple trees are not self-fertile in most cases. They require pollen from a different apple variety flowering at the same time to produce fruit. If your apple tree is the only apple tree in your garden, and there are no other apple trees within about fifty metres in neighbouring gardens, pollination may be the problem.
The solution is either to plant a second apple variety nearby that flowers at the same time, or, if planting is not practical, to identify whether there are suitable pollinator trees in the immediate neighbourhood. In the older residential areas of Grange-over-Sands, Kendal and Ulverston where gardens are close together and many properties have established apple trees, pollination is less often the problem because trees in adjacent gardens provide pollen. In more isolated rural properties or where neighbouring gardens have changed and old apple trees have been removed, it can become the issue.
If you are not sure whether pollination is the problem, look at whether the apple flowers are setting small fruitlets in early summer and then dropping off, which suggests pollination is occurring but the fruits are failing to develop, or whether no fruit at all develops after flowering, which more strongly suggests a pollination problem.
The Pruning Has Been Wrong
This is the second most common cause of poor fruiting in older garden apple trees. Apple trees fruit on spurs, which are the short stubby growths that develop on older wood over many years. Pruning that removes too much of the fruiting spur system, or that cuts back heavily to long whippy shoots and removes the fruiting wood, significantly reduces fruit production.
Equally, a tree that has never been pruned and has become very large and congested may eventually stop fruiting well because the interior of the tree is too shaded for fruiting spurs to be productive. A balance between maintaining enough old spur wood and keeping the canopy sufficiently open for light to penetrate is what good apple tree pruning aims for.
If your apple tree has been pruned, or you have had someone in to prune it, and fruiting has declined since then, the pruning approach may need reviewing. Apple trees should be pruned in winter while dormant. Summer pruning of established apple trees is also beneficial for restricting growth and encouraging spur development, but requires specific knowledge of where to cut.
The Tree is Overcropped and Biennial Bearing
Some apple varieties, and older trees generally, tend toward biennial bearing, producing a very heavy crop one year and almost nothing the next. The heavy crop year exhausts the tree's resources, leaving insufficient energy for fruit bud formation for the following year. This cycle, once established, can be self-perpetuating.
The traditional remedy is fruit thinning in the heavy year, reducing the number of developing fruitlets on each spur to one per cluster in early summer. This prevents the tree from overcropping, allows the retained fruits to develop to a better size and quality, and preserves enough of the tree's energy for fruit bud formation for the following year. Consistent thinning over several years can gradually break a biennial bearing pattern.
The Tree is Too Old or in Decline
Very old apple trees, of which there are a number in the older gardens of Grange-over-Sands and the surrounding villages, eventually decline in vigour to the point where fruit production becomes poor regardless of management. Signs of this include very small, congested spur systems with little productive new growth, dieback in the outer crown, and generally reduced vigour and leaf size.
Old apple trees can sometimes be rejuvenated through careful renovation pruning over several years, which involves gradually removing congested old spur systems and the least productive framework branches to encourage new growth. This is skilled work and not something to tackle without some knowledge of what you are doing. If you have a very old apple tree that has declined in productivity and you are not sure whether it can be brought back, we are happy to have a look and give you an honest view.
Frost Damage to the Blossom
Late frosts in April and May, which are not uncommon in parts of Cumbria, can damage or destroy apple blossom and developing fruitlets. A frost event that coincides with the peak of blossom can eliminate the year's crop entirely on vulnerable trees. Trees in frost pockets, in low-lying ground where cold air settles, or in sheltered positions that encourage early blossom before the frost risk has passed, are most susceptible.
There is limited practical intervention available beyond protecting small trees with fleece during late frost forecasts in spring. Choosing late-flowering varieties is the best long-term approach for gardens in frost-prone positions in Cumbria.
Get Advice on Your Garden Trees in Cumbria
Phone/WhatsApp: 07376804724
Email: enquiries@maxreynoldstreeservices.com
Contact us here | Tree pruning services | Tree surgeon Grange-over-Sands and Cartmel | Tree surgeon Kendal